Former choir leader guilty in case involving high school teen
A Lancaster County jury sided with the student and convicted McMillan of nearly a dozen charges Friday afternoon.
McMillan sat silently as the jury pronounced him guilty of five counts of involuntary deviate sexual intercourse, four counts of statutory sexual assault and one count each of indecent assault and corruption of minors.
Earlier Friday, McMillan, 27, of Lancaster, testified on his own behalf, and he admitted he had the sexual relationship with the student but told the jury he believed the girl was 16 years old.
“It was a very, very bad call of judgment,” McMillan told the jury. “I just should’ve been more responsible.”
But the girl, now 19, fake id reddit testified Thursday that McMillan specifically asked her age, knew exactly what year she was in school and had access to school records all before they began having sex in November 2005.
Jurors began deliberating shortly after noon and less than one hour later announced they had reached a verdict.
The teenager’s aunt, sitting with the victim in the front row of the spectator section, covered her face and wiped tears from her eyes as the seven men and five women stood and pronounced McMillan guilty on all counts.
Judge Jeffery Wright ordered a background investigation and a psychological evaluation of McMillan before he imposes sentence.
After the jurors and spectators left the courtroom, McMillan’s mother, clutching a worn Bible, cried softly, and she called out “I love you” to her son as he was led away in handcuffs.
McMillan’s case was one of five similar incidents of Lancaster County music instructors having inappropriate relationships with teenage girls and the last to be resolved in court.
The former McCaskey Gospel Choir director was arrested by city police Detective Andrew Morgan in May 2008 and has remained in county prison since that time.
On the witness stand Friday morning, McMillan was smiling and confident as he told the jury how he taught the girl to drive in the high school parking lot and drove her to apply for a job.
Those reasons, plus her work at a church camp, idreddit.com McMillan said, led him to believe she was 16 years old. Sixteen is the legal age of consent in Pennsylvania.
Assistant District Attorney Rebecca Franz used the defendant’s statements against him in her closing argument.
McMillan testified, Franz noted, that he first met the girl when she was a freshman, and he described her as well spoken and intelligent.
“She’s not the kind of student inclined to be held back for years,” Franz said.
“This isn’t a case where she met the defendant in a bar and used fake ID to get in. He met her as choir director in high school when she was a freshman,” Franz said. “He knew exactly how old she was.”
Defense attorney Douglas A. Conrad told the jury in his closing argument that the school district used “bad judgment in hiring such a young person to teach other young people.”
And his client, Conrad added, “used bad judgment in having a relationship with a student any student it’s not right.”
Conrad pointed to the testimony of two of McMillan’s colleagues who helped with the school choir.
Clifton Jenkins and the Rev. Ronald Taliaferro both testified for the defense that McMillan would not have had access to class lists, school records or computers, scannable fake id Conrad said.
The teenager, in her testimony, told the jury that the couple had sex at the school, in McMillan’s car, at his home or at the home of one of his friends.
In May or June 2006, she said, they agreed to end the relationship when rumors started circulating about the time they were spending together.
The school district terminated McMillan in September 2006 after the school learned of the alleged relationship. A month later, she said, they hired an attorney to file a lawsuit against the school district. The civil lawsuit is pending, officials said.